By Leslie Rohonczy, IMC™, PCC, Executive Coach, Leadership Expert, Speaker, Author
MAY 2025
There’s a weird myth about confidence out there, and I don't have a hot clue where it came from. It's the idea that you’re either born with confidence or you’re not. That some people are just lucky enough to “have it.” And the rest of us…? Well, sorry about our luck.
Like so many of us, I bought into that myth for a long time. And honestly? It just kept me small. Safe. Protected from... what? Judgment? From being seen as 'too much', 'too loud', taking up too much space?
If you’re thinking, "Yeah, me too," you're in good company! So many of us are not born confident. I certainly wasn't! I had to build it, brick by wobbly brick. Through late-night doubts, shaky first steps, awkward experiments, and moments when my inner critic fired up the flamethrower and scorched my ass.
I learned along the way that confidence isn’t something you’re handed. It’s something you create.
Here’s how.
Confidence Isn’t Magic – It’s Motion (and a New Deal with Failure)
If I had waited until I “felt ready,” I’d still be sitting on the sidelines, perfectly preparing. But confidence doesn’t come from waiting. It comes from moving – from taking imperfect, courageous action before you feel fully prepared.
I really wish someone had told me this little nugget sooner: make friends with failure. Not the dramatic, life-or-death, fatal flaw kind of failure. I mean the everyday, small, awkward misses; the times when things don’t land quite the way you hoped.
Early on, I thought every stumble I made seemed to confirm a limiting belief I had that I wasn’t good enough. Now I see it differently: if I’m learning, it's not failure – it's just data. Feedback. An indicator of growth. It’s your brain using that new data to learn, course-correct, and get sharper for next time.
One of the biggest confidence boosts you can give yourself after a stumble is learning to say, "I’m not there... yet." The real magic is in the willingness to reframe, reflect, tweak, and try again.
Confidence doesn’t mean you’ll never fall. It means you trust yourself to get up, dust off, and take a next step, smarter for having tried.
Confidence Comes from Owning Your 'Ness', Not Borrowing Someone Else's
In my early leadership days, I thought if I could just act like some of the impressive leaders around me, I’d finally feel confident. Spoiler alert: copying others just didn't work. Sure, there's some truth to the old 'fake it til you make it' chestnut, but every time I tried to wear someone else’s leadership “suit,” it felt stiff and exhausting, like I was showing up to a marathon in a full hazmat suit.
Real confidence didn’t click for me until I started leading with my own ‘Leslie-ness’ – the gifts and abilities that made me unique: my creativity, ability to connect dots, love of emotional intelligence, voracious curiosity, and powerful questions.
Confidence isn’t about volume, bravado, or mimicking. It’s about alignment and letting your best, truest self lead the way. You have your own 'ness,' too, and trust me, it’s your biggest asset!
Your Inner Critic Isn’t Going Away – But You Can Change the Relationship
Even today, after all the hard work and awareness-building, my inner critic still pipes up sometimes (I call her 'Mimi', after the Drew Carey Show character Mimi Bobek haha!) She says things like: "Are you sure you’re ready for this?" "Maybe you should wait until you’re better prepared." "Don't be so bold! Everyone will think you're a showoff!"
I used to think confidence meant silencing that voice. In fact, I've wanted to throw Mimi into the trunk of my car and push it off a cliff many times! But that never works, because our Inner Critics have an important job: they try to keep us safe by making us aware of something they think we’re not aware of. (They just have a weird way of going about it!)
Today I realize that I don't need to kill 'Mimi', I just need to keep her out of the driver’s seat. When I notice that she is starting to fire up, I picture her riding in the backseat of my car; hands off the wheel and no access to the radio, thank you very much! And I’m the only one allowed to choose the route. (Thanks to Liz Gilbert for this wonderful idea!)
You don’t have to eradicate self-doubt to be confident. You just have to stop letting it make your decisions.
Failure Isn’t Fatal – It’s Fuel
We’ve all heard the term ‘failing fast,’ usually tossed around by well-meaning leaders who want to encourage quicker thinking and braver experiments. It's meant to free us from worrying about getting everything perfect, to help us be more confident, and to nudge us into trying bolder, out-of-the-box ideas. And while those intentions are good, true failure is still emotionally messy, discouraging, and painful.
I understand it differently now: Failure isn’t a dead end. It’s just an unintended result. When something doesn’t go the way I'd hoped, I’ve learned to step back and ask: What part worked? What part didn’t? What did I learn that I can apply next time?
Over the years, I've been steadily building this reflection muscle, and while it hasn't always been easy, it has helped me turn misses into insights and wobbly results into stepping stones. Confidence grows when you realize you’re not fragile, flawed, or failing; you’re learning, adapting, and getting stronger.
Confidence Is a Practice, Not a Personality Trait
If you’re waiting to magically feel confident all the time, let me save you the suspense: you’ll be waiting forever. Confidence isn’t a trophy you win once and display forever. It’s a living, breathing practice.
Some days it flows through you easily. Other days, you’ll have to dust it off and rebuild it, piece by piece. And that’s normal. But every time you step up, even when you’re unsure, you’re proving something important to yourself: that you can handle the unknown; that you can learn as you go; and that you are braver and stronger than your fear.
If confidence has ever felt like something other people had and you didn’t, hear this message loud and clear: it’s not something you’re born with; it’s something you build, one imperfect action at a time; one courageous experiment at a time; one “not yet” moment at a time.
So go ahead, take up your space. Say the thing. Try the new way. Wobble your way forward. The future you (the one who already knows you are enough and that you belong), is cheering you on.
And so am I.